Answer to Jung: Making Sense of 'The Red Book'
Check Price on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases

Answer to Jung: Making Sense of 'The Red Book'

Expert Analysis (Click for details)
Learning Effectiveness
Overall Score 2.0/5
Strengths
The author's personal story and the mystery of Jung's text may engage readers emotionally. The close reading format encourages careful attention to the original material.
Limitations
There are no interactive elements, self-assessment tools, or reinforcement mechanisms. The argument is presented as a single narrative without opportunities for the reader to test or apply concepts.
Recommendations
Engaging for a niche audience but not designed for active learning or knowledge retention in a structured educational setting.
Loading decision snapshot…

The Red Book is C.G. Jung’s record of a period of deep penetration into his unconscious mind in a process that he called ‘active imagination’, undertaken during his mid-life period. Answer to Jung: Making Sense of ‘The Red Book’ provides a close reading of this magnificent yet perplexing text and its fascinating images, and demonstrates that the fantasies in The Red Book are not entirely original, but that their plots, characters and symbolism are remarkably similar to some of the higher degree rituals of Continental Freemasonry. It argues that the fantasies may be memories of a series of terrifying initiatory ordeals, possibly undergone in childhood, using altered or spurious versions of these Masonic rites. It then compares these initiatory scenarios with accounts of ritual trauma that have been reported since the 1980s. This is the first full-length study of The Red Book to focus on the fantasies themselves and provide such an external explanation for them. Sonu Shamdasani describes The Red Book as an incomplete task that Jung left to posterity as a ‘message in a bottle’ that would someday come ashore. Answer to Jung brings its message to shore, providing a coherent, but disturbing, interpretation of each of the fantasies and their accompanying images. Chapters: Chapter 4 of this book is freely available as a downloadable Open Access PDF at http://www.taylorfrancis.com under a Creative Commons [Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives (CC-BY-NC-ND)] 4.0 license. Read more

About This Book

The Red Book is C.G. Jung’s record of a period of deep penetration into his unconscious mind in a process that he called ‘active imagination’, undertaken during his mid-life period. Answer to Jung: Making Sense of ‘The Red Book’ provides a close reading of this magnificent yet perplexing text and its fascinating images, and demonstrates that the fantasies in The Red Book are not entirely original, but that their plots, characters and symbolism are remarkably similar to some of the higher degree rituals of Continental Freemasonry. It argues that the fantasies may be memories of a series of terrifying initiatory ordeals, possibly undergone in childhood, using altered or spurious versions of these Masonic rites. It then compares these initiatory scenarios with accounts of ritual trauma that have been reported since the 1980s. This is the first full-length study of The Red Book to focus on the fantasies themselves and provide such an external explanation for them. Sonu Shamdasani describes The Red Book as an incomplete task that Jung left to posterity as a ‘message in a bottle’ that would someday come ashore. Answer to Jung brings its message to shore, providing a coherent, but disturbing, interpretation of each of the fantasies and their accompanying images. Chapters: Chapter 4 of this book is freely available as a downloadable Open Access PDF at http://www.taylorfrancis.com under a Creative Commons [Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives (CC-BY-NC-ND)] 4.0 license. Read more

ISBN-139781138312395
ISBN-101138312398
PublisherRoutledge
Publication DateNovember 2018
Edition1
Pages184
LanguageEnglish
Dimensions6.14 x 0.46 x 9.21 inches
Weight11.2 ounces

Expert Analysis & Insights

In-depth editorial assessment across key dimensions

5 dimensions analyzed
Learning Effectiveness
2.0

The author's personal story and the mystery of Jung's text may engage readers emotionally. The close reading format encourages careful attention to the original material.

Engaging for a niche audience but not designed for active learning or knowledge retention in a structured educational setting.

Knowledge Depth
2.0

The book provides a detailed, entry-by-entry analysis of Liber Primus, Liber Secundus, and Scrutinies, with attention to both text and images. It also engages with historical context on Freemasonry and ritual abuse literature.

Suitable for readers seeking a highly specialized interpretation but not as a general reference on Jung's work.

Research Utility
2.0

The author provides historical references on Freemasonry and cites survivor reports and her own prior research on artists like Francis Bacon and Samuel Beckett. The book raises a novel hypothesis linking Jung's fantasies to spurious Masonic rituals and childhood trauma, which could stimulate further scholarly debate.

May be of interest to scholars of Jung, trauma studies, or the history of esoteric practices, but should be read as a speculative and unverified hypothesis rather than a definitive academic study.

Reference Quality
1.0

The table of contents lists each fantasy entry with page numbers in both the facsimile and reader's editions, which aids navigation for those studying The Red Book alongside this text.

Not recommended as a reference work; at best a companion guide for sequential reading of The Red Book.

Curriculum Alignment
1.0

None identified from the provided metadata.

No place in formal training programs.